Friday, January 31, 2025

PACE grants Georgian delegation limited credentials until April

The Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe (PACE) approved a resolution on Georgia, granting limited credentials to the Georgian delegation until April.

The resolution outlines several conditions that Georgian authorities must satisfy by April, among them “the release of political prisoners and the announcement of new elections.”

If the criteria are not satisfied, Assembly members will have the opportunity to challenge the Georgian delegation’s credentials in April.

Below is the draft resolution in full:

1.The Parliamentary Assembly recalls that by acceding to the Council of Europe on 27 January 1999, Georgia agreed to honour several specific commitments listed in Assembly Opinion 209 (1999), as well as the obligations incumbent on all member States under Article 3 of the Statute of the Council of Europe (STE No. 1): compliance with the principles of pluralist democracy and the rule of law as well as respect for human rights and fundamental freedoms of all persons placed under its jurisdiction.

2. In its Resolution 2561 (2024) “Challenges to democracy in Georgia”, the Assembly already expressed its deep concern at the continuing and rapid backsliding of democracy in Georgia. Noting that the 26 October 2024 parliamentary elections would be a de facto referendum on Georgia’s democratic trajectory and foreign alignment, the Assembly reiterated its commitment to co-operation and dialogue with all forces and civil society in Georgia “to reverse the recent backsliding and to uphold the honouring of Georgia’s membership obligations and commitments to the Council of Europe”.

3.The latest developments confirm the Assembly’s concerns. The findings of the Assembly’s election observation delegation “raise concerns about the correctness of the election results, namely whether the election results truly reflect the will of the voters. Additionally, serious doubts persist regarding whether the electoral environment provided the necessary conditions for a fair election, enabling voters to make an informed choice free from intimidation and undue pressure. This is reflected in the response from the opposition and civil society, which have expressed deep mistrust in both the results and the institutions and continue to challenge the outcome of the election”. Following the elections, large demonstrations erupted in Georgia, with opposition parties boycotting parliament and asking for a rerun of the vote.

4. Street demonstrations took even larger proportions following the announcement that the government would suspend Georgia’s European Union accession process. This decision, which is contrary to the ruling party’s electoral promises, has resulted in a social crisis characterised by a complete breakdown of trust in the political institutions of the country in the eyes of the Georgian society, which compromises their legitimacy. It is also bound to have an impact on the introduction of much needed reforms that would help tackle Georgia’s democratic backsliding.

5. The Assembly condemns the human rights abuses committed by the police, including the brutal use of force against demonstrators, in violation of freedom of assembly, in the context of a progressive erosion of fundamental rights and freedoms, the dismantling of democratic safeguards, the shrinking space for civil society and the politicisation of State institutions that began well before these elections. It also condemns the misuse of the judicial system to deter and retaliate against protesters, journalists and opposition figures, issues which so far remain unaddressed by the authorities.

6. In this respect, the Assembly asks the Georgian authorities to take into account the recommendations to be made by the European Commission for Democracy through Law (Venice Commission) in its urgent Opinion on the Law on Administrative Offenses, requested by the President of the Assembly. Likewise, the Assembly reiterates its call on the authorities to repeal the Law on Transparency of Foreign Influence in its current form, to protect freedom of assembly and expression and to ensure accountability for human rights violations and end stigmatisation of NGOs, as highlighted also by the Council of Europe Commissioner for Human Rights during his visit to Georgia in January 2025.

7. In the Assembly’s view, Georgia’s political deadlock and breach of trust between the authorities and civil society can be overcome only through:

  1. a clear recommitment of the Georgian authorities to Council of Europe values and standards and further European integration in line with the European aspirations of the majority of the Georgian people;
  2. a reinforced process of engagement with the Council of Europe, involving the Georgian authorities as well as a wide range of other Georgian stakeholders;
  3. an inclusive political process in Georgia involving all stakeholders and social actors, including opposition and civil society, to urgently address the deficiencies and shortcomings noted during the recent parliamentary elections; the organisation of new genuinely democratic elections, held under strict international monitoring and conditions of political independence of State institutions and election administration;
  4. ensuring accountability for all law enforcement officials involved in violent crackdowns against peaceful protesters, beatings, mistreatment, torture and arbitrary arrest;
  5. the release of all political prisoners.

8. In this regard, the Assembly recalls the visit which the Secretary General of the Council of Europe carried out in Tbilisi in December 2024, following which a number of initiatives were launched.

9. Similarly, the Assembly recalls that its co-rapporteurs of the Committee on the Honouring of Obligations and Commitments by Member States of the Council of Europe (Monitoring Committee) visited Georgia in January 2025, and met interlocutors from the Georgian institutions, as well as all political forces, NGOs and civil society.

10. Developments since the 26 October 2024 parliamentary elections, including violations of the freedom of assembly and expression and the crackdown on the opposition and civil society, are in contradiction to Georgia’s membership obligations and accession commitments to the Council of Europe. The Assembly therefore needs clear assurances from the authorities that they are genuinely committed to reversing the democratic backsliding and fulfilling their membership obligations.

11. “The Assembly resolves not to ratify the credentials of the Georgian Delegation and as a signal of its own openness to maintaining dialogue, the Assembly, pending a reconsideration of the Georgian delegation’s credentials and an overall re-assessment of the situation in the country at its April 2025 part-session, decides to ratify at this part-session the credentials of the Georgian delegation while, at the same time, insisting that the Georgian authorities:

  1. immediately initiate an inclusive process involving all stakeholders and social actors, including the ruling majority, opposition and civil society, to urgently address the deficiencies and shortcomings noted during the recent parliamentary elections and to create an electoral environment that is conducive to genuinely democratic new elections to be announced during the coming months
  2. take immediate and effective steps to enable Georgia to resume the European integration process, in line with the European aspirations of the people, and to accelerate with determination the necessary reforms;
  3. put an immediate end to police brutality and human rights abuses, effectively investigate these practices and end the misuse of legal proceedings as a means of deterring or retaliating against protesters, journalists and civic leaders, and fully respect the right to freedom of expression and assembly;
  4. step up co-operation with the Council of Europe and engage in good faith in the process initiated by the Secretary General of the Council of Europe;
  5. address, without delay, the concerns and recommendations of the Assembly expressed in Resolution 2438 (2022) and Resolution 2561 (2024), including the recommendation to revoke the Law on Transparency of Foreign Influence, and the concerns about the Law on Administrative Offences, which should be addressed by taking into account the urgent opinions of the Venice Commission;
  6. release all political prisoners before the 2025 April part-session of the Assembly;
  7. continue to engage fully with the Assembly’s monitoring procedure and work to ensure that monitoring mechanisms function effectively during the pre-election period, thereby strengthening timely warnings against any democratic decline;

12. Furthermore, the Assembly calls on the Georgian authorities to:

  1. take immediate and effective steps to enable Georgia to continue the EU accession process, in line with the European aspirations of the people, and to accelerate with determination the necessary reforms; step up cooperation with the Council of Europe and engage in good faith in the process initiated by the Secretary General of the Council of Europe;
  2. continue to engage fully with the Assembly’s monitoring procedures.”
ქეთევან ნინუაhttp://tiflisnews.ge
საინფორმაციო სააგენტო tiflisnews.ge კონტაქტი- ☎️ 557 13 16 73

FM Botchorishvili: Georgia ready to strengthen regional stability, mediate peace efforts among neighbours

The centuries-old friendship and robust cooperation between Georgia and Armenia have now been elevated to the level of a strategic partnership, stated Georgian Foreign Minister Maka Botchorishvili during a joint briefing with Armenian Foreign Minister Ararat Mirzoyan. Botchorishvili emphasized that Armenia traditionally ranks among Georgia’s top ten trade partners, highlighting the strong tourism ties between the two nations. “It is a great honour to be in Yerevan on my first official visit as Foreign Minister. I sincerely thank Minister Ararat Mirzoyan for his hospitality. Exactly one year ago, Georgia and Armenia signed a strategic partnership declaration in Tbilisi. Our deep-rooted friendship and close cooperation are now framed within this strategic partnership, encompassing diverse areas of collaboration. Armenia remains one of Georgia’s key trade partners, and Armenian citizens rank third among the most frequent visitors to Georgia. Today, we explored avenues to enhance our cooperation in trade, economy, transport, tourism, education, and beyond. While our partnership is extensive, there is always room for growth. I am pleased that my colleague and I are firmly committed to further deepening our bilateral ties,” Botchorishvili stated. She also noted that the 14th session of the Armenia-Georgia Intergovernmental Economic Commission, co-chaired by both countries’ Prime Ministers, would take place in Yerevan—an opportunity to discuss high-level strategies for advancing multidimensional cooperation. “We value regular political dialogue. The intensity of our cooperation and the frequency of high-level visits are commendable. I am confident that I will continue to visit your beautiful country, just as I look forward to welcoming you to Georgia. During our discussions, we addressed regional developments and the crucial importance of peace and stability. Georgia remains committed to fostering lasting peace in the region, which is essential for the prosperity of the Caucasus. We hope the ongoing Armenia-Azerbaijan peace negotiations will yield a mutually acceptable outcome, laying the groundwork for lasting stability. Georgia has always been—and remains—ready to contribute to regional cooperation for the benefit of all. We also discussed the security challenges posed by Russia’s occupation of two Georgian regions, which has resulted in severe humanitarian, economic, and social consequences,” she added. Botchorishvili reaffirmed the steadfast support that both Georgia and Armenia extend to each other’s sovereignty and territorial integrity. She also extended an invitation to her Armenian counterpart to visit Tbilisi. “We had a detailed discussion on regional dynamics, challenges, and opportunities. We believe in joining efforts to address these challenges and advance mutually beneficial projects. Georgia welcomes Armenia’s strengthened engagement with the European Union and the United States,” she concluded.

Vasil Maghlaperidze: We are filled with great sympathy towards Mzia Amaglobeli; this issue should be resolved through balance of humanity, forgiveness, justice

“I am filled with great sympathy for Mzia Amaglobeli. We, as a society, are also victims. We got to this situation together. I’ve heard many positive things about her. Whatever happened, happened. I do not believe we in Georgia are debating whether or not to slap each other, even the police officer. At the same time, as a single person, I anticipate great humanity,” remarked Vasil Maghlaperidze, the Chairman of the Georgian Public Broadcaster’s Board of Trustees, in an interview with GPB’s ‘Aktualuri Tema’ (Actual Topic) program. According to him, all First Channel employees stand in solidarity, and society should strive for reconciliation and mutual understanding. “I wish the First Channel could do something and that displaying placards and cursing at us would assist in settling the problem. Fine, if it helps, but I believe this issue should be handled by striking a balance between humanity, forgiveness, and justice. Let’s say directly what concerns people – one is the standard of justice. Let’s use this for our common country, not for political purposes. Let’s not slap each other, not spit in each other’s dishes, and not curse each other’s mothers. The blame placed on the First Channel for this issue should be on the conscience of those who do this. First Channel journalists are behaving very dignifiedly and will continue to do so. If the First Channel has the slightest ability, everyone should be assured that it will take every necessary step. This is a great pain for First Channel journalists, and they want the situation solved on humane terms. However, we are also stating that we should not slap each other. I am filled with this optimism. As previously said, the First Channel will always do its best. Even if I wasn’t present, this would not require a board or parity. We’re not in kindergarten to lecture people. It is not essential because the major collective is already present,” remarked Vasil Maghlaperidze. The Chairman of the Board of Trustees believes that “increasing the temperature will not help to solve the situation.” “Let us hope that humanism wins inside us and that we return to the human ideals from which we have wandered off little. We need to return to human principles in time,” said Vasil Maghlaperidze.

PM: Journalist Mzia Amaglobeli “acted as party activist,” not as reporter during police incident

“Mzia Amaglobeli’s offence was in no way related to journalistic activities; she was acting there as a party activist. Therefore, linking this incident to the media is pure speculation,” declared Georgian Prime Minister Irakli Kobakhidze speaking live on Imedi TV. According to the Head of Government, the police are one of the most respected state institutions in the eyes of the Georgian people, and Mzia Amaglobeli was deliberately attempting to undermine the reputation of this institution. “This is the Saakashvili scenario 2.0. You know how Saakashvili’s scenario ended in its time. He was on a hunger strike for months, on and off, but the state naturally took care of his health, just as it does for any prisoner’s health. This responsibility falls on the state as well. Of course, we wish everyone good health, and the state is accountable for the health of any prisoner. Regarding the incident itself, it began when Mzia Amaglobeli was placing stickers on police officers; she was subsequently arrested, and conditionally released, and as soon as she was free, she slapped a police officer in the face. Thus, her actions were in no way connected to journalistic endeavours; she was acting as a party activist. Therefore, any attempt to link this incident to the media is absolute speculation. When we speak of humanity, an action can be deemed humane if it is accompanied by remorse—in that case, one could talk about humanity. Otherwise, such an action can only be seen as a manifestation of inadequacy. Had these individuals come forward and simply stated that this lady behaved inappropriately and that one cannot insult a police officer, who is a representative of the state? You know that the police are one of the most respected institutions in the eyes of the Georgian people. She went out and demonstratively sought to tarnish the image of this state institution. This entire episode served no other purpose. She shows no remorse, neither does she nor her fellow party members from the ‘collective National Movement.’ At times like these, they talk about how a person is on a hunger strike and should therefore be released from prison,” stated the Prime Minister. Kobakhidze mentioned that he continually expresses readiness for dialogue on any issue, including the case of Mzia Amaglobeli. “We repeatedly, continuously express our readiness for dialogue. I can reaffirm now that we are ready. If anyone wishes to discuss any issue, whether publicly or privately, specifically regarding Mzia Amaglobeli, let them come—I’m set to meet tomorrow and discuss this matter. You probably recall that previously, at various times, whether concerning the law, elections, or these protests, I requested meetings in any location, in any format, both public and private discussions. Every request was rejected. I suggested specific individuals, including, if I am not mistaken when Shota Arveladze appeared on your broadcast and indicated that the government wasn’t engaging with those inclined toward protest. I invited him to bring anyone he wanted. They didn’t even show up to discuss the football stadium issue today, let alone political matters. What more could we discuss if they have questions or are interested in something? If anyone is avoiding discussion, it is precisely the protest participants because they understand that they are not right; the truth is not on their side. They simply are convinced that they must be ‘Natsi’ and must adhere rigidly to their established viewpoint. They are not ready for a discussion because they know the truth isn’t on their side. This is the sole reason. If anyone wants to talk in any format, whether publicly or privately, let them come and engage in conversation. Let’s discuss any issue,” noted the Prime Minister.

PM dubs Tsulukiani’s decision to withdraw from PACE as having no alternative

“Tea Tsulukiani’s decision was absolutely without alternative, and in this situation, our delegation will not continue working in the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe,” declared Georgian Prime Minister Irakli Kobakhidze during a broadcast on Imedi TV. According to the Head of Government, this decision in no way changes the situation in Georgia. “This decision shows that European bureaucracy is in quite a difficult state. This applies to both Brussels and Strasbourg. What we witnessed today is another manifestation of this injustice. More than injustice, it was an absolutely absurd decision. They approved our delegation, thereby recognizing the election results. At the same time, they stated that if elections are not held by April, they will cancel our delegation’s credentials. In other words, they recognize the election results but still want elections to be held simply because someone’s favourite political force, the collective National Movement, lost. Such absurd decisions show that European bureaucracy is in a dire state. However, this does not fundamentally change the situation for our country. The decision announced by Tea Tsulukiani on behalf of our delegation and team was crucial. This decision was absolutely without an alternative. In this situation, our delegation will not continue working in the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe, will cease its work, and the delegation will be withdrawn from the Parliamentary Assembly by the Georgian Parliament. If the attitude towards the Georgian people and our country changes, of course, we will return to PACE, but in the current situation we see today, there is absolutely no point in working there. This is a simple matter – this decision had no substantial significance for our country, though the absurdity of this decision is an aspect that deserves analysis,” stated the Prime Minister.

PM: Radical opposition works against state interests but will achieve nothing

“Everywhere there is a radical opposition, there is work being done against the interests of the state; however, they will achieve no outcomes today or in the future,” stated Georgian Prime Minister Irakli Kobakhidze live on Imedi TV. As the Head of Government highlighted, the opposition has been active behind the scenes, attempting to prevent the approval of the Georgian delegation at the Parliamentary Assembly of the Council of Europe. “You can see what the opposition has been doing—they were roaming the hallways, working to ensure that our country’s delegation would not be approved. They ultimately did not achieve that result, as a decision was made to approve the delegation’s credentials as planned, which was their primary goal. They did not reach their target but created a kind of intermediate effect in the form of a resolution. Everywhere there is radical opposition, there is work being done against the state interests. However, they accomplished nothing today and will achieve nothing in the future,” Irakli Kobakhidze concluded.

Latest News